A very cruel game begins in earnest on April Fool’s day this year. I should have written about it sooner, but my excuse is a preoccupation with government plans for privatising us. In the process though I’ve completely neglected the impending plight for many of our charges.
If you didn’t know better you might think the government had unknowingly or accidentally decided to declare war on a significant section of the population, but of course the welfare ‘reforms’ are entirely deliberate and ironically will do nothing but hinder any attempt at a ‘rehabilitation revolution.’
Many, if not most, clients of the probation service are in receipt of State Benefit of one kind or another and as a group have never been particularly good at managing their limited incomes, often due to chaotic lifestyles involving either drink or drugs. A significant number have either learning disabilities or mental health problems that means coping on very tight budgets is extra difficult and there is a danger that spending decisions will not always be prudent. Of course the politically-correct would say it was about ‘choice’ and helps to encourage ‘responsibility’.
As a consequence, much of a probation officer’s time has always had to be devoted to helping clients manage crisis situations brought about by a severe lack of money. I can tell you it’s draining and extremely depressing for us, let alone the poor client, and often forms an effective barrier to any work we might wish to undertake concerning offending behaviour. But it’s going to get a whole lot worse from Monday and as Polly Toynbee of the Guardian says, it will be the day that defines this government.
Interestingly, as I write this, Grant Shapps, the Conservative Party chairman cites the present system as being cruel and hence justification for ‘reforms’, thus flying in the face of the new Archbishop of Canterbury and other church leaders who are quite-rightly pointing out they will hit the vulnerable.
Even before the new measures take effect, we know through leaked internal memos from the Department of Work and Pensions that Job Centre staff are being required to ‘sanction’ as many claimants as possible and try and trip them up at ‘botherability’ interviews. As always, this despicable tactic will mostly catch the scared and vulnerable, rather than the undeserving malingerers. As one staff member puts it, suicides will result, indeed just as we’ve seen with the infamous Atos capability tests designed to throw as many people off Disability Living allowance as possible.
The saddest bit of all in this new twist to a cruel game is that many, many claimants have no idea what’s about to hit them. In effect the changes in Council Tax Benefit, which will now only be a ‘contribution’ towards the total, coupled with the so-called Bedroom Tax, is in many ways a reincarnation of the despised Thatcher Community Charge or Poll Tax of the 90′s. In one fell swoop, hundreds of thousands of claimants will see their benefit reduce significantly over night due to ‘under-occupancy’ and with virtually no hope of being able to move easily to smaller accommodation and retain their rights as tenants of social landlords.
As if this wasn’t bad enough, payments will be made monthly instead of fortnightly and in respect of Housing Benefit, direct to the claimant and not the landlord anymore. Everyone aware of the situation knows that arrears of rent are going to accumulate quickly as many clients find it difficult or impossible to make up the shortfall, together with the extra responsibility of managing finances on a monthly basis. This is a gift to the ‘payday’ and door-to-door loan sharks as many claimants will feel pushed into their arms as a misguided way of coping.
There is no doubt that the number of evictions will increase and many clients of ours will simply be unable to cope. They will be pushed over the edge. The final twist in this cruel game of making the poorest and most vulnerable pay for the mess we’ve got into, is that all new claims for benefit will have to be made online FFS. Can someone tell me how homeless, vulnerable and often chaotic people trying to get back into mainstream life can get easy access to a secure e-mail account, especially with libraries closing?
I see a massive amount of extra welfare-type work for the probation service and other statutory agencies, especially as funding for Citizen Advice Bureau’s and civil Legal Aid have been dramatically cut. I wonder if any of this is making those carpet baggers currently sizing up contracts for probation work think twice? These ‘reforms’ are hardly going to assist with their efforts at making money out of the ‘rehabilitation revolution’ under PbR are they?
Even after these punitive cuts and with benefit levels capped at 1% for three years, thus ensuring inflation does its bit to help make the poorest even poorer, and before the Universal Benefit changes come into effect, astonishingly I see that the government is saying that the total welfare budget is not expected to reduce, merely that any increase will be ‘managed.’
It seems even more radical measures to cut ‘welfare dependency’ could be on the way with the government feeling increasingly confident that the public mood is behind the deliberate widening of the division between the deserving and undeserving poor. This cannot be good for the well-being of any civilised society and I see the potential for serious trouble and unrest ahead.
Some are saying that April 1st 2013 marks the beginning of the end of the Welfare State as we know it. On this day massive changes also come into effect as to how NHS services are commissioned, thus opening the door not just to more privatisation, but appallingly plenty of scope for many of these new commissioners to feather their own nest, despite supposed conflict of interest policies.
As expected, the No10 petition has topped 20,000. You can sign it here.
Courtesy of Jim Brown via On Probation Blog